Edit ModuleShow Tags

To Catch a Killer


(page 6 of 7)

The detectives arrested Westerfield and brought him back to police headquarters. “You could just sense the anger in the air,” the source says. “People were pissed off. Holmes was so mad he was pale. Holmes had it out with Creighton, almost to the point where Holmes thought he was going to be transferred.”

(Assistant Chief Creighton had no comment, citing the gag order. San Diego Magazine also contacted Lieutenant Collins, Sergeant Holmes and Detective Thrasher. They either did not return phone messages, or declined comment because of the gag order.)

When Police Chief David Bejarano went on live TV and gave Ott and Keyser credit for the arrest, the anger only intensified. “It really, really, really pissed people off,” says another cop. “Those two got credit for what robbery did.”

Homicide Lieutenant Duncan has an entirely different memory of that day. “I’ve been a San Diego police officer for more than 30 years,” he says. “But when we arrested Mr. Westerfield, and when we put that case together, I was never more proud of being a San Diego police officer than I was at that moment. To me, that was the whole spirit of this thing.”

Westerfield was now in custody, but it would be five more days before searchers found Danielle’s body. “It was unbelievable, the kind of pressure everybody was under,” says a source. “In their hearts, they wanted to get that little girl back. They didn’t want to see her laying out there, ending up the way she did. It was a very emotional time for everybody.”

As Westerfield sat in a holding cell in homicide, Ott and Keyser reportedly briefed their sergeant, Bill Holmes, about the arrest. “That’s when Newman comes back,” says one source. “Newman wants to know if Westerfield said anything, if he told them where Danielle is. Newman tells Holmes, ‘Send Ott and Keyser back in there ... find out where that little girl’s at.’

“Holmes tells him, ‘Captain, he’s got a lawyer. Are you sure you want me to send my guys back in there? They could be sued.’

“Newman’s response is: ‘I don’t care. I want to know where that little girl’s at.’”

(Contacted twice for this story, Newman twice offered “No comment” for the record.)

Since Danielle’s disappearance, the cops assigned to the case had been working 18 to 19 hours a day, every day. They were taking it personally. They were thinking of their own children. Danielle wasn’t just another missing person. She was their little girl.

“Put it this way,” says one cop. “There were a few tears shed by some pretty experienced investigators. You don’t see that very often.”

On February 27, a volunteer search party discovered Danielle’s body in a field off Dehesa Road in East County. It took more than a day for SDPD to process the crime scene. Around 5 p.m. on February 28, investigators decided they’d collected all the evidence they were going to find.

It was time to go home, but that’s not what cops do. Nearby Singing Hills Golf Course had been providing food and water to everyone at the scene. So the detectives and their supervisors decided to go to the bar at the golf course.

But according to two sources, Newman told Ott and Keyser to take crime-scene photos of Danielle’s body to the jail to show to Westerfield. “Newman told them to go down there and show him the photos, and make sure they tape-recorded it,” one source says. “He wanted to see the exact photos Ott and Keyser were going to show him.”

So Ott and Keyser headed for the jail, while everybody else went to the bar at Singing Hills. “It wasn’t a celebration,” says an insider. “Guys were just kinda winding down. People had been working nonstop on this thing, so they were having a drink, relaxing ... doing the cop thing.”
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags

More »Related Stories

San Diego's Top Doctors 2019

A healthy helping of the breakthroughs and on-the-rise practices sweeping San Diego's medical community

How San Diego Are You?

Take our quiz to see where you land on the newcomer to old-timer spectrum

Women Firsts in San Diego

16 women get candid about getting there first in their field
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags

Most Popular

  1. The Best of San Diego 2019
    Our annual compilation of everything delicious, cool, and Instagrammable in San Diego (and Baja!)
  2. The Problem With Bright Red Tuna
    Many Americans still think bright red tuna means it’s fresher (it’s not)
  3. First Look: Animae
    Puffer Malarkey Restaurants unveil 5.5 million-dollar pan-Asian concept
  4. Jason Mraz and his Historic Coffee Bean
    The singer and Bird Rock Coffee Roasters unveil the first California-grown Geisha coffee
  5. Morning Glory Is a Millennial Wonderland
    The Little Italy restaurant may finally break San Diego's aversion to brunch
  6. A Deep Dive into the San Diego Fishing Industry
    A $2 billion project is poised to revive San Diego’s commercial fishing industry
Edit ModuleShow Tags


Not Your Grandma's Orthotics

New year, new – shoe? Staying on your feet for long hours at a time just got a whole lot more comfortable with Wiivv’s BASE custom insoles

October is Rideshare Month

Join the Rideshare 2015 Challenge and get there together
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit Module
Edit Module

Connect With Us:

Edit ModuleShow Tags


The Vape Debate

Two Scripps doctors weigh in on this dangerous trend

Kaiser Permanente San Diego Makes Life Easier

Kaiser Permanente brings high quality, affordable care to San Diegans when and where they need it
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit Module Edit Module
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags