Everyday Eats: Nessie Sandwich at Supernatural Sandwiches

Scoop up some "sea to sandwich" fare at the SD Public Market.

Roaming among fresh produce and pastries at the San Diego Public Market can be hunger-inducing, and while there are free samples galore, sometimes a mini meal of citrus segments and pita dipped in hummus aren't going to cut it. Luckily, there are plenty of prepared food options to quiet a growling stomach, including my current favorite, Supernatural Sandwiches. At the food stand in the Market Hall, Chef Christian Eggert (and crew) transform fresh fish into approachably gourmet sandwiches. He calls it "sea to sandwich" cuisine, while I'm going to go with "magically delicious" -- mostly because even though I'm iffy on fish, the Nessie sandwich ($9) instantly won me over. It's one of the shop's "supernatural seven" -- a collection of fish-centric sandwiches named after mythical sea creatures. Other options include the Neptune (scallops and bacon with spicy aioli), the Kappa (a crab melt with white cheddar), and the Siren, a garlicky shrimp sandwich with taqueria-style hot sauce. All sandwiches are are under $10.

From day to day, the featured fish on the Nessie sandwich changes, and can include anything from yellowtail to sablefish -- all sourced from Catalina Offshore. Sunday's fresh catch was fluke, a white fish with a mild flavor. The flaky filet is sauteed and brushed with the shop's "shinto" glaze (a sweet miso), then topped with marinated tomatoes, lettuce, and a ribbon of citrus aioli. 

All of the components are precisely executed and play well together. The sweet glaze complements the bright, mixed citrus aioli, and the tomato relish brought some crunch and tang. It's a great option for pre- or post-shopping, and so tasty that it's worthy of a visit simply on its own merit.

Supernatural Sandwiches is located in the San Diego Public Market, 1735 National Ave. in Barrio Logan (map). Sandwiches are available during market hours (9 a.m. to 2 p.m., Wednesdays and Sundays)

Everyday Eats: Tacos at Puesto
veryday Eats: The Californian at Zanzibar Cafe

Add your comment:
Edit ModuleShow Tags

Food and Drink

Restaurant reviews and food trends in San Diego

About This Blog

Restaurant reviews, food trends, top cocktails, wine, beer and generally the best eats and drinks in San Diego, with reporting (read: eating) lead by food editor Troy Johnson. Looking for the Erins? Erin Chambers Smith and Erin Meanley? Find their most recent musings over at the Around Town blog. And yes, we know that one needs a new name. We're working on it. 



Atom Feed Subscribe to the Food and Drink Feed »

Recent Posts

Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit Module Edit Module
Edit ModuleShow Tags


Come See What’s New in Palm Springs

This SoCal city is constantly reinventing the landscape with new places to stay and play

Win Tickets to the 42nd Annual SDCCU Holiday Bowl

This year’s USC vs. Iowa match-up marks the Holiday Bowl’s third straight paring of teams that are ranked nationally in the top 25
Edit ModuleShow Tags

Most Popular

  1. The Best Chicken Wings In San Diego
    The results of food critic Troy Johnson’s epic quest for the city’s best tiny chicken
  2. San Diego's Best New Restaurants of 2019
    From a 200 million-dollar renovation project to a dirty little burger, these made a dent
  3. The Must-Try Dishes of 2019
    SD Mag food critic and Food Network judge Troy Johnson names his top dishes of the year
  4. Video: A Peek At Our Insiders Club
    For members only…New perks, insider info and access to the editors
  5. The SoCal (Social Calendar!)
    From black-tie galas to costumed 5Ks, these events will keep your social calendar full—and you feeling good
  6. Where to Celebrate New Year's Eve in San Diego 2020
    Whether you’re celebrating the end of a decade or the beginning of a new one, these are fine choices of venue.
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit Module