Edit ModuleShow Tags

The Truth Is Grayer Than It Seems in San Diego Rep’s ‘Actually’

Beyond the simple facts of a Title IX case, this play opens a bigger conversation about the innumerable factors behind every decision we make


Published:

DeLeon Dallas and Emily Shain in 'Actually' | photo by Jim Carmody

I never mastered the “elevator pitch.” How do you distill a complex story into a quick soundbite? Common as the question is, I dread hearing “What’s it about?” because the answer to that can be entirely separate from “What happens?”

No quick summary of Anna Ziegler’s Actually can do it justice. For better or worse, it has the fortune of being a play “about” Title IX, student sexual assault, consent, and contradictory he said/she said perspectives opening the same month these lightning-rod issues have dominated the national conversation. But I’m here to assure you: If you’re weary of personal trauma being excavated before a skeptical audience, this play is not a polemic and spends comparatively little time in the “trial” itself. Likewise, if you do care deeply about seeing a just, nuanced representation of the women and men involved in these cases, nothing about this story can be reduced to a rage-inducing clickbait headline.

When the cast and set are this minimal—just two actors and two chairs—you can’t afford any slack. Lucky for us, Emily Shain and DeLeon Dallas are engaging storytellers, whose monologues are vivid and smartly paced from beginning to end, full of acute observations on the experience of being a college freshman from two distinct perspectives. They and director Jesca Prudencio are all MFA graduates from UC San Diego, and they clearly have a finely honed rapport that radiates confidence in their craft. The barebones set naturally draws greater attention to the lighting and sound design (by Chris Rynne and Melanie Chen Cole, respectively), and it’s impressive how evocative a single warped guitar note or sudden shift from crossed to parallel spotlights becomes when deployed at exactly the right moment.

Emily Shain and DeLeon Dallas are engaging storytellers, whose monologues are vivid and smartly paced from beginning to end.

Through seemingly tangential anecdotes, cleverly staged reenactments, and personal appeals, both our actors bring to life not only the events immediately surrounding The Night in Question, but a full portrait of who their characters are as people: all the unpigeonholeable factors that’ve shaped them up to that one crucial moment. It leaves room for a lot of humor and insight, and I think it’s fair to say this is the biggest point the play wants to make: That when the difference between innocence and guilt rests on a mere “preponderance of evidence” (i.e., “50 percent and a feather,” or far less than the legal standard of “beyond a reasonable doubt”), and the way that last feather falls depends only on conflicting accounts and subjective experience, it becomes impossible to consider all the relevant circumstances in the span of a single hearing, precisely because all the circumstances are relevant.

My other biggest takeaway was overwhelming abashedness, recognizing by experience how ill-equipped any of us are at age 18 to deal with all the societal and emotional issues wrapped up in sex and dating, and how futile it can seem to expect anyone to act in a self-consistent and accountable way while immersed in a culture of such constant, heavy drinking. You’ll leave the show sympathetic to and critical of both characters, unsure where to place judgment or even whether judgment is warranted, and grappling with the challenging notion that the truth of a matter is often more than the sum of its facts.


Actually
at Lyceum Theatre through November 4
Tickets at sdrep.org

Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags

More »Related Stories

The Problem With Bright Red Tuna

Many Americans still think bright red tuna means it’s fresher (it’s not)

Being a Teenage Tudor Is Bloody Business In 'The Virgin Trial'

Cygnet’s new production proves you don’t get to be queen of England by staying innocent

History and Diversity Highlighted at 2019 California Craft Beer Summit

Craft beer experts from around the U.S. shared tips on how to take beer into the future
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags Edit Module Edit Module
Edit ModuleShow Tags

Sponsored

We Chat With Richard Blais About What’s Cooking at KAABOO This Year

Sponsored by KAABOO Del Mar

Wheelhouse Credit Union Reopens Downtown Branch

Completely remodeled branch brings a modern service experience to members
Edit ModuleShow Tags

Most Popular

  1. The Best of San Diego 2019
    Our annual compilation of everything delicious, cool, and Instagrammable in San Diego (and Baja!)
  2. Where to Watch the Fireworks in San Diego this Independence Day
    Where to catch the fireworks displays in every corner of the county
  3. What Will San Diego Look like in 2069?
    The City of San Diego is 250! Instead of looking back, we asked experts to predict how our city will look in 50 more years.
  4. The Best San Diego Happy Hours to Get You Through the Week
    All the best spots to take advantage of drink specials, cheap bites and more, from Pacific Beach to South Park
  5. Morning Glory Is a Millennial Wonderland
    The Little Italy restaurant may finally break San Diego's aversion to brunch
  6. A Deep Dive into the San Diego Fishing Industry
    A $2 billion project is poised to revive San Diego’s commercial fishing industry
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit Module